Why two suitable lenses may fail to focus inside a tube

The lenses give a sharp view when held separately, but the assembled tube reaches the end of its travel before the blur disappears. The optics may be suitable; the required relative position is simply beyond the housing’s range.

To build an educational refractor, first find the required positions of the real lenses and the available travel, then cut the tubes to their final lengths. Focal length, the length of a piece of plastic and lens separation are different quantities. Cells and the overlap of the sliding parts also affect that separation.

We will work through one documented build and a complete method for checking its dimensions. We checked the documentation and calculations; we have not physically assembled or tested this instrument. Without parts, you can still work through the numerical example and prepare a dimension sheet without buying equipment.

This educational telescope is not intended for observing the Sun. Never point it at the Sun; eclipse glasses do not make such a telescope safe. The checks below require an ordinary non-solar target in a safe direction. NASA: safety with optical instruments.

Choose one design and one lens pair

Our starting point is Simple PVC-pipe Telescope by University of Hawaiʻi physics professor Pui Lam, revised 25 August 2006. It includes an optics list, cell photographs, sliding plastic tubes and a check of lens spacing before cutting. Old prices and shop stock numbers are not a current supply specification. Pui Lam: instructions, pp. 2–5.

For this route we select the positive double-convex objective, nominally +500 mm focal length and 50 mm diameter, and the positive double-convex eyepiece, +50 mm focal length and 38 mm diameter. The objective creates a real intermediate image; the eyepiece lets us inspect it under a larger angle. This is a Keplerian arrangement with an inverted view. The −75 mm negative eyepiece also listed in the instructions needs a different position; it is not substituted into this specification.

A simple single-element objective has chromatic and other errors. This build teaches focusing, orientation, cells and pointing; it does not replace making or testing a good achromat. The correction differences are explained in the article on achromats and apochromats.

Branch · Optical budgetOptional · you can skip this

What nominal +500 and +50 mm provide

For thin lenses in air and an infinitely distant object, with parallel output bundles:

d_(∞) = f_(o) + f_(e) = 550 mm, M = − (f_(o))/(f_(e)) = − 10.

d is the distance between equivalent optical planes, and M is angular magnification. The minus sign indicates inversion. These equations omit thickness, aberrations and any added image erector. OpenStax: two positive lenses, Fig. 2.41 and Eq. 2.40.

Below, we explicitly add a front paper stop with an opening D=40 mm. If it is the limiting aperture of the incoming axial bundle, then f_(o)/D = 12.5, and the exit pupil at this 10× setting is:

p = (D)/(∣M∣) = 4 mm.

This is an image of the entrance aperture near the eye, not an image of the target. The 50 mm lens diameter cannot replace the 40 mm clear opening in that calculation. These numbers describe the specified infinity setting, rather than every finite target distance. Nikon: effective aperture and exit pupil.

A parts list must describe seats and openings too

Use this list to check the particular parts you already have or intend to use. Similar-looking caps are not necessarily interchangeable.

AssemblyDocumented starting point and required check
ObjectiveDouble-convex converging lens, 50 mm diameter, nominal +500 mm focal length. Check focus and edge seating without pressure on optical surfaces.
EyepieceDouble-convex converging lens, 38 mm diameter, nominal +50 mm focal length. Check the eyepiece cell fit; diameter does not specify focal length.
Outer tubeThe source uses nominal 2″ SCH40, cut after trial alignment. Actual inside and outside diameters are required.
Inner tubeNominal 1½″ SCH40, sliding inside the outer tube on friction pads. Check travel, alignment and overlap.
Front cellOpen threaded fitting for a 2″ tube, paper gasket and soft edge support following the source photographs. Measure the lens reference position from the tube end.
Objective gasketSource dimensions: 1.8″=45.72 mm inside, 2.2″=55.88 mm outside. Its outer edge seats in the fitting, not necessarily inside the tube itself.
Aperture stopOur added paper mask with a 40 mm opening, centred on the objective; outer contour matched to the gasket seat. Check that the other openings pass this bundle.
Rear cellThe source uses a 1½″→1¼″ reducer and threaded cap; the internal lip is modified before fitting the eyepiece. Check the supporting rim, clear opening and axial lens position.
Guides and supportThe source shows four friction pads. A separate stable support should hold the outer tube while leaving the inner one free to slide.

The source instructions do not specify material grades or coatings for these ready-made lenses. Quantifying chromatic errors needs the properties of the actual parts; a datasheet for a different glass cannot automatically be assigned to this pair.

The gasket and threaded retention follow Pui Lam’s photographs and explanation, pp. 4–5. The 40 mm mask is explicitly our addition, not a part attributed to the original author. A front cap, gaskets or tilt may limit light before the lens diameter does.

Optics, cells and sliding parts do different jobs
12345678
  1. Front cell
  2. Our stop with a 40 mm opening
  3. Objective: 50 mm diameter, f≈+500 mm
  4. Outer tube
  5. Friction guides
  6. Sliding inner tube
  7. Eyepiece: 38 mm diameter, f≈+50 mm
  8. Reducer and retaining cap

Schematic exploded arrangement, without a seating dimension scale. Based on Pui Lam, pp. 2–5; the 40 mm stop is our explicit addition. Parts are separated to explain assembly; this is not a ray path or the universal shape of a plumbing fitting.

A tube’s nominal size is not an exact measurement. For example, the Spears table for its SCH40 lists a 60.325 mm outside diameter and 51.9938 mm average inside diameter for 2″; the corresponding 1½″ values are 48.26 and 40.386 mm. These explain nesting and the need for guides. A metric tube labelled “50 mm” or a random plumbing reducer may have different dimensions. Measure the particular pair and seats; do not cut threads into the thin pipe itself to imitate the appearance. Spears: SCH40 table, pp. 75–76.

Find the image before committing to the housing

Secure the objective in a trial cell and point it at an illuminated, high-contrast non-solar target. Move white or translucent paper behind the lens until the sharpest real image becomes visible. It may be small and faint; inspect the screen from the side, without pointing the instrument at a dangerously bright source.

That plane belongs to the chosen target distance. To estimate the objective focal length, the author recommends a target much farther away than 100 focal lengths: over 50 m for a 500 mm lens. At shorter distances, include the distance in the calculation instead of calling the lens-to-paper distance the infinity focal length. Pui Lam: preliminary exercise, p. 6.

Place the eyepiece behind the image plane and find a position for sharp viewing. Then remove the paper: it marked a plane and is not a permanent part of the visual telescope. Keep the lens orientations unchanged and put one fixed reference mark on each cell, stationary relative to its lens. Record the distance between these marks when the view is sharp. Final alignment uses the actual sharp view, because an educational lens may have an approximate stated focal length.

Branch · Finite target distanceOptional · you can skip this

Why a 10 m target needs another 26.32 mm

In the thin-lens model, let R be the object-to-objective distance and v the objective-to-real-image distance. For R > f_(o):

(1)/(f_(o)) = (1)/(R) + (1)/(v), v = (f_(o)R)/(R − f_(o)), v − f_(o) = ((f_(o))^(2))/(R − f_(o)).

For parallel eyepiece output, its front focus must coincide with this plane: d(R) = v + f_(e). With f_(o) = 500 mm and R = 10 000 mm, we obtain v ≈ 526.32 mm and d ≈ 576.32 mm. Compared with infinity, the eyepiece moves outward by about 26.32 mm. At 5 m the required spacing is already about 605.56 mm. OpenStax: thin-lens equation.

For an on-axis object point, a ray entering at height y has slope y/R; after the objective its slope is y/R − y/f_(o). Its height becomes zero at distance v. An eyepiece another f_(e) farther on makes the outgoing rays parallel. This independently checks the sign and direction of the required movement; it is not our measurement of a finished tube.

A nearer target moves the intermediate image and eyepiece outward

Target at infinity

OIE

Target at 10 m

OIE

O — Objective; I — Intermediate image; E — Eyepiece

R is target distance; v is O→I; d is O→E; Δ is the shift from the infinity setting.

Rv, mmd, mmΔ, mmIn range?
∞500.00550.000.00Yes
50 m505.05555.055.05Yes
10 m526.32576.3226.32Yes
5 m555.56605.5655.56No

Thin +500/+50 mm lenses in air, 40 mm opening, on-axis object point; distances from optical planes. Both panels share scales; transverse scale is enlarged relative to the longitudinal one. The 10 m source lies off-frame to the left. Aberrations, thickness and diffraction are not calculated. The table tests only the hypothetical 540–590 mm mechanical window, not physical fittings.

Connect lens spacing to every mechanical dimension

Before cutting, record for your set: the spacing between the two cell marks at sharp focus for the farthest and nearest working targets; each mark’s position relative to its tube end; the stable overlap range; and margins to both travel limits. Call this measured distance d_(m). Measure along the tube axis between transverse planes through the marks. Measure the cells in the same assembled state you will use later.

For thick lenses, mechanical references do not automatically coincide with principal optical planes. Cutting does not require guessing those planes: a sharp view and fixed marks provide the required d_(m) directly. In the numerical example, we separately assume that the mark planes coincide with the thin-lens planes, allowing comparison between d_(m) and calculated d.

Captions in the original guide give approximately 290 mm for the main tube and 260 mm for the inner tube. The author explicitly requires finding working lens positions first. Those dimensions therefore describe his example; they should not replace your own dimension sheet.

Add both tube lengths and the signed offsets of the selected reference marks, then subtract overlap to obtain the mechanical spacing between marks. Less overlap means greater spacing. Check both ends of the required travel so that accommodating a nearby target does not remove the ability to focus on a distant one.

Cell reference marks and tube ends have separate coordinates
L_A = 330L_B = 300q = 140eₒeₑdₘ = 550.00

Hypothetical dimensional example in mm: L_A=330, L_B=300, e_o=e_e=+30, q=140, d_m=550. Horizontal coordinates agree with the model; transverse dimensions and wall thicknesses are schematic. Offsets are assigned example values, not measurements of commercial cells. Red marks indicate cell reference planes; only in this example do they coincide with the thin lenses. Positive e points outward; a recessed plane needs negative e.

Branch · Length budgetOptional · you can skip this

Check the cutting plan and travel margin numerically

Let tube lengths be L_(A) and L_(B), with overlap q. The selected front mark plane extends from the front tube end by e_(o); the rear mark plane extends from the rear end by e_(e). Both are positive outward; a recessed plane has a negative offset. Geometry for the measured mechanical references gives:

d_(m) = L_(A) + L_(B) − q + e_(o) + e_(e).

A hypothetical consistent example: L_(A) = 330 mm, L_(B) = 300 mm, e_(o) = e_(e) = 30 mm. These are assigned educational values, not measurements of Pui Lam’s fittings; the mark planes are assumed coincident with the thin lenses. If suitable overlap ranges from 100 to 150 mm:

d_(m) = 690 mm − q, 540 mm ≤ d_(m) ≤ 590 mm.

Infinity requires q=140 mm; a 10 m target needs about 113.68 mm. Both lie inside the window. A 5 m target requires q≈84.44 mm, below the chosen limit, so this configuration cannot reach that target. Do not extend beyond the permitted overlap just to obtain focus.

This example has 10 mm of inward travel from nominal infinity focus and about 13.68 mm outward from the 10 m position. That is a margin for the assigned values, not a lens tolerance or a guarantee of mechanical stability. With different cell mark positions, insert your own signed offsets and d_(m) measured at sharp focus; choose and check the overlap interval on your trial assembly before cutting. Every required quantity has a place in the equation rather than remaining an assumption based on a photograph.

Cells retain the optics while guides allow focusing

Prepare empty plastic parts and gaskets first: modify and cut before installing optics, then remove burrs and debris. Support the objective at its edge on a suitable seat and soft support so it cannot fall through the opening; the gasket and cap retain it without strongly clamping optical surfaces. The eyepiece likewise needs edge support instead of rattling inside the reducer. Follow the separated parts in the original instructions, p. 4.

Arrange friction pads around the inner tube to prevent its axis sagging sideways while keeping movement smooth. Check the entire required travel before fitting final stops. Pads, paper lining and any extra layer consume radial clearance; all belong in the actual fit check.

Closed side gaps and a dark matte interior help reduce stray light. The source tubes are already black; if you add a secured dark paper lining, it must not peel off, restrict the working opening or interfere with guides. Such surfaces cannot correct chromatic aberration. The role of a housing in excluding unwanted light is described by Edmund Optics: housing and mounting.

For trial tabletop viewing, support the outer tube in two padded cradles and prevent it rolling; leave the inner section movable. This supplements the source design and is not a mount we have physically tested. Pointing should not drift unpredictably after a light touch on the focuser. If the support slips or the tube wobbles noticeably, address that first; a shaking image cannot reliably establish optical sharpness. Use an appropriate attachment to a stable support for work away from the table, accounting for the particular housing.

One symptom may have several causes: check them separately

SymptomSeparate checkNext action
No image on the screenRemove the eyepiece; check pointing, target illumination and the objective’s signFind a real image outside the housing before rebuilding the whole tube
Sharpness improves up to the travel limitCompare the measured required dₘ with the mechanical window; include target distance RCorrect the length budget while retaining the necessary overlap
Image moves when the inner tube rotatesCheck edge seats, pads and alignmentRemove play or tilt before assessing the optics
Coloured edges remain after focusingCompare sharpness of different colours at the centreRecall the limits of a singlet objective; extra travel cannot make it an achromat
Centre is sharp, edges worseCompare the same detail at the centre and edgeSeparate off-axis errors from overall defocus
Little field is visible or its edge darkensReposition the eye; check clear openings and centringDistinguish eye position from housing vignetting; do not infer field solely from D/f
Bright veil or reflectionShade side illumination without blocking the targetCheck gaps and shiny interior areas
Image shakesObserve without touching the tube and check the support separatelyStabilize the mechanics before judging sharpness
Writing is invertedCompare the orientation of the whole targetFor two positive lenses this is expected, rather than an assembly defect

The table gives a sequence of checks, not a remote diagnosis of a particular product. Optical principles and colour-correction limits follow the preceding articles; mechanical actions apply to checked seats without arbitrary strong lens clamping.

The learning result is to explain what worked

Start with one high-contrast target: locate its image on paper, restore viewing with the eyepiece, and record orientation and focus position. Repeat at another known distance and compare the direction of movement with the calculation. Do not assign results more precision than the ruler, lenses and pointing method provide.

For the sky, this simple instrument can be an educational step towards observing bright objects, but we cannot guarantee particular details or quality. Reliable support and understandable pointing come first. More magnification cannot replace aperture, correction and stability.

You can now explain why cut lengths do not equal the sum of focal lengths, why a nearby target requires greater extension and why identical pipe labels do not guarantee a fit. Revisit lens signs in the comparison of Galilean and Keplerian designs and precision and coatings in the article on optical manufacturing. The next family in the course gathers light with a primary mirror: Newtonian reflectors.