Good optics need a support that responds to your hand

You point a telescope at the Moon, release the tube, and it rises. Fit a heavier eyepiece and the tube starts dropping instead. Even a correctly shaped mirror cannot help if following the sky becomes a struggle against the mechanics.

A Dobsonian telescope combines Newtonian optics with a simple support on two axes. The tube rises on large side bearings, while the upper assembly turns in azimuth on a ground board. Sufficient stiffness, suitable sliding surfaces and balance let motion start smoothly and keep the telescope pointing when released. The light path is explained in the Newtonian reflector article.

John Dobson popularized affordable telescopes for public observing. According to the Sidewalk Astronomers’ own history, the organization began in 1968 and also taught inexpensive telescope making. This dates the spread of a practical approach, not the invention of Newtonian optics or of two-axis mounts. Sidewalk Astronomers: organizational history, Stellafane: optics and mount.

We will follow one documented route using a finished primary and a flat secondary mirror. Making your own mirror is a separate option. The author has not physically built or tested this telescope: the following distinguishes Stellafane’s instructions, our calculations and checks to perform in a real workshop.

Start with one consistent set of dimensions

Our reference is the nominal Stellafane Yellow, 6″ f/7.5 design. One inch equals exactly 25.4 mm. It is a small ground-based visual instrument for the Moon, planets, double stars and sufficiently bright extended objects. Visibility of the latter depends on sky darkness and light pollution. This version allows no extra focus height for a camera; fitting a camera into the opening does not establish compatibility.

AssemblyConsistent specification
Primary mirrorParabolic, diameter 152.4 mm, nominal focal length 1143 mm; a small full-thickness mirror suitable for the simple cell described
SecondaryFlat, front-surface coating, minor axis 33.02 mm; holder matched to that size
Cardboard tubeInside diameter 203.2 mm, wall 3.175 mm, outside diameter 209.55 mm; initial length 1219.2 mm
Focuser2″ fitting, 50.8 mm clear bore, minimum height 64.008 mm above the outer tube wall
Spare inward travel6.35 mm for eyepiece focal-plane positions; this is not total focuser travel
Tube endsPrimary surface to rear edge 114.3 mm; focuser axis to front edge also 114.3 mm
WoodCell and altitude bearings in 19.05 mm plywood; cradle box in 12.7 mm; other thicknesses below
Sliding surfacesSolid PTFE pads and suitable textured laminate; three feet under the base

Our calculation gives a 1196.467 mm tube; loading Yellow in Newt-Web returns the same 47.105″. We also checked primary-to-focuser distance and the calculator’s absence of warnings about clipping the specified beams. This verifies a design, not a finished instrument. Stellafane: Yellow parameters, checking the design, Newt-Web.

Make a dimensional record of your actual components: mirror focal length, glass diameter and thickness, real tube diameters, cell geometry, focuser height and travel, drawtube intrusion, and eyepiece interfaces. A nominal “8-inch” concrete-form tube can have a different diameter because several sizes nest inside one another. Changing one part calls for a fresh compatibility check. Stellafane: selecting and measuring the tube.

Useful tools include a ruler, square, large-radius compass, saw, drill, edge-shaping tools and clamps for trial assembly. Check perpendicularity with the square, symmetry from common layout marks and fit with the actual mating part. A precise number on paper replaces none of those checks.

The tube and mount are two connected assemblies

12345678
  1. Primary mirror and cell
  2. Tube
  3. Secondary and support
  4. Focuser
  5. Adjustable cradle
  6. Altitude bearings
  7. Rocker box
  8. Azimuth base and feet
Functional exploded diagram based on Stellafane. Parts have been moved apart and use different scales; this is not a cutting template. The cradle holds the tube, the bearings turn in the rocker, and the rocker glides on the ground board. Diagram basis: Stellafane.

Place the focus above the focuser with travel to spare

The primary starts converging the light; the secondary turns the converging beam sideways. Primary-to-secondary distance is shorter than the full focal length because the remaining path runs from secondary to the external focal plane. A wider tube or taller focuser requires the beam to turn earlier.

Our nominal set needs 175.133 mm from axis fold to focus and 967.867 mm from primary to fold. The eyepiece must place its own focal plane at that external focus. Its shoulder, which rests on the focuser, need not coincide with its focal plane. Check inward reserve and actual travel for every eyepiece and adapter.

Budget the focus before drilling holes

967.8671234
  1. Primary: vertex datum
  2. Optical-axis fold
  3. Focal plane
  4. Tube ends
Distancemm
Primary to fold967.867
Fold to focus175.133
Total focal length1,143
Calculated tube length1,196.467
Both axes use the same scale. The dashed route measures the axis; it is not an unobstructed central ray. Secondary offset and attachment details are omitted. Values are nominal Yellow dimensions; check actual focus before cutting. Diagram basis: Yellow.

Branch · Optical budgetOptional · you can skip this

Where the 175 mm goes, and why eyepieces need different travel

Let Rₒ=104.775 mm be the tube’s outside radius, h=64.008 mm the focuser’s minimum height and q=6.35 mm the chosen inward reserve. Let b denote fold-to-focus distance, l primary-to-fold distance and T tube length. The axial budget is:

b = R_(o) + h + q = 175.133 mm, l = f − b = 967.867 mm, T = 114.3 + l + 114.3 = 1196.467 mm.

Unfolding the bend makes l+b equal f=1143 mm again, an independent geometric check. This is a nominal budget for a distant object, not a correction for a nearby indoor target.

Define δ as the eyepiece focal plane’s displacement outward from its seating shoulder, and e as focuser extension from fully racked in. Then:

e = q − δ, 0 ≤ e ≤ t,

where t is total useful travel. Two hypothetical eyepieces with δ=+3 mm and −4 mm need e=3.35 mm and 10.35 mm. A focuser with verified travel of at least 25.4 mm covers both positions. With δ=+7 mm, e would be negative: the focuser has already reached its inward stop, and further outward travel cannot help. Adapter height also belongs in δ; these δ values are teaching inputs, not specifications of particular products.

A nearby target shifts focus outward. For target distance u, the paraxial extra-path estimate is f²/(u−f). With f=1143 mm and u=1.6 km, it is about 0.817 mm; a star removes that correction too. Focusing on an indoor wall does not establish that stellar focus is reachable.

The cell supports the mirror and allows it to tilt

A small full-thickness mirror can use a simple ventilated cell. Stellafane’s version has two plywood parts: a lower part fitted to the tube bore and an upper part carrying the mirror. Three spring-loaded pull bolts set tilt; three additional push bolts lock the adjustment. Back off the push bolts during collimation, then bring them into contact without changing tilt. Stellafane: cell function, materials and hardware.

For two 19.05 mm panels, the source specifies ¼‑20 hardware: three 63.5 mm pull bolts, three 38.1 mm push bolts, six tee nuts, six washers and three wing nuts. The three compression springs are 9.525 mm in diameter and 19.05 mm long. Push bolts bear on metal plates rather than soft plywood. The ¼‑20 designation means an inch thread with 20 threads per inch, not metric M6. Changing the hardware requires matching holes, nuts, springs and adjustment range again.

In the parametric drawing, D=152.4 mm gives a pull-bolt circle of D−25.4=127 mm and a push-bolt circle of D−63.5=88.9 mm, with three directions 120° apart. Lay out both panels from a common centre and check paired holes in a trial assembly. Gradually fit the lower panel to a sliding fit without forcing the cardboard out of round. Ventilation openings preserve airflow. The PDF is drawn for a different bore, 7⅞″: do not copy it as a finished 8″ template. Stellafane: construction and two-page plan.

The source uses flexible adhesive supports in this version, with temporary spacers preserving thickness during curing. Use a material compatible with the surfaces, appropriate preparation and its specified curing time. An old generalization that sealants are interchangeable cannot establish compatibility. If using a compatible manufactured cell with clips, the clips prevent escape rather than pressing hard on the optical surface. Side restraints must also avoid squeezing the glass. Stellafane: mounting and pinched optics.

First check the empty cell: springs partly compressed, adjustment available both ways and no binding bolts. Remove the glass during drilling, shaping and painting; clean the finished parts before returning the optics. A thin or much larger mirror needs a new support analysis. Scaling up these three contacts does not prove suitability.

Lay out the focuser and secondary from common references

Draw a straight longitudinal reference line and mark the focuser axis 114.3 mm from the front edge. Size the large opening for the drawtube’s outside diameter: the 50.8 mm clear bore is not a drill-hole diameter. Use washers, secure the focuser rigidly and avoid crushing the cardboard by overtightening. Check full travel and whether the lower edge intrudes into either the required incoming or outgoing beam. Stellafane: installing the focuser.

The author’s particular drawtube had a 57.15 mm outside diameter and a 60.325 mm opening. That illustrates clearance for that component, not a universal standard for 2-inch focusers. Transfer mounting holes from the actual base after a trial fit.

One documented secondary assembly uses a thin curved metal vane, wooden hub, threaded rod and a 45° holder. For a 33.02 mm minor-axis mirror, the authors used a 31.75 mm hardwood dowel. The curved vane sits across the focuser axis, supporting the assembly while allowing adjustment. Curvature redistributes diffraction rather than eliminating it. Stellafane: making the holder.

This version uses stainless steel about 0.508 mm thick and a 76.2 mm long ¼‑20 rod. Make holder and hub from hardwood; check the angled cut, aligned hole and adjustment range before attaching the finished secondary. Keep black paint off the adhesive contact face.

The source’s secondary adhesive arrangement has three small separated contacts on the clean mirror back. Temporary spacers preserve a gap and are removed after full curing according to the compatible adhesive’s instructions. Check retention separately before installing it above the primary. Self-adhesive foam tape is not equivalent to verified attachment: the source reports heat-related failures. Stellafane: attaching the secondary.

Locate vane mounting points from the actual secondary’s front reflecting surface. Set adjustment near midrange, measure from the surface centre to the attachment holes, then transfer that layout to the tube. A cardboard disc with its centre marked helps position the hub. Preserve secondary translation, rotation and tilt adjustment; looking through the focuser, it must face towards the primary. Stellafane: vane installation and rough alignment.

Branch · Obstruction and fieldOptional · you can skip this

Why secondary size depends on focuser height

In an unfolded paraxial model, the axial cone’s diameter at the secondary plane is Db/f. With D=152.4 mm and b=175.133 mm, that is 23.351 mm. A d=33.02 mm secondary leaves room for off-axis field bundles. The fully illuminated focal-field diameter C is:

C = (d − Db/f)/(1 − b/f) ≈ 11.419 mm.

Similar triangles give the formula: bundle radius Db/(2f), plus centre displacement C(1−b/f)/2, must fit within d/2. An independent check is Newt-Web’s 0.450″, about 11.43 mm after rounding. This is the central focal-plane area; a wider field may remain useful with gradually falling illumination. It does not imply a sudden black boundary at 11.4 mm.

The primary area geometrically obscured by the secondary alone is (d/D)²≈0.04694, or 4.69%. Holder, vane and reflectivity are separate contributions. Diffraction cannot be assessed by replacing aperture with D−d.

This is a bundle-envelope calculation using thin planes, not exact off-axis tracing of a tilted ellipse. A real assembly must account for offset, holder, mounts and drawtube. A taller focuser increases b and the cone width near the secondary, so an “almost identical” focuser can require another mirror size.

An image determines the final cell position

Secure the primary temporarily at its calculated location, support the tube and check a distant target or star. Do not leave a heavy mirror relying on accidental friction or an unsecured tube. Choose daytime targets well away from the Sun; this route is for night astronomy and includes no solar configuration.

The sequence is rough alignment → low-power focusing → checking every eyepiece and adapter → recording available travel both ways. If a nearby image is sharp but a star needs more inward travel, revise the optical budget. Moving the primary towards the secondary pushes focus farther outward; leave reserve instead of achieving only one end-stop position. Stellafane: testing before permanent holes.

The instruction itself demonstrates the value: after testing, the authors changed the cell-back insertion depth from 2⅜″ to 3¾″ and attributed the difference to an incorrectly measured mirror focal length. Do not transfer those as-built holes to the nominal Yellow f/7.5 in our table. Test your own optics first, fix the position, remove the assemblies, then make the final tube cut and apply finishes. The inside needs a dark matt surface to suppress stray light; the outside needs moisture protection.

The cradle lets the tube slide and rotate

The tube sits in a wooden cradle carrying the altitude bearings. For a 209.55 mm outside diameter, use a 304.8 mm cradle length, 222.25×304.8 mm top and bottom panels and two 260.35×304.8 mm sides, all in 12.7 mm plywood. The resulting outside width is 247.65 mm. These are coordinated geometric dimensions; measure actual plywood and felt thickness.

Eight corner triangles in the adjustable version contact the tube through felt. The lower four are fixed; the upper four are paired on pressure beams. Two knobs vary beam pressure, while retaining bolts prevent the beams falling out. Releasing pressure lets the tube slide for balance or rotate the eyepiece towards a comfortable viewing position. Tightening should retain the tube without deforming its circular section. Stellafane: adjustable cradle dimensions and assembly.

The triangles and beams use 19.05 mm plywood. Two 38.1 mm wide beams run the cradle’s length. There are four 76.2 mm retaining bolts and two 50.8 mm pressure bolts, all ¼‑20. Six tee nuts, locking hardware, washers and two knobs complete the mechanism; pressure bolts bear on metal plates on the beams. These lengths belong to this section, so another plywood thickness calls for new checks.

Lay out the triangles from a full-size section including pad thickness. Trial-fit before final finishing: the tube must enter, move when released and stay secure when clamped. Self-adhesive felt glue is not the only retention mechanism; the authors report hot-weather adhesive failure and tube slippage. Their suggested mechanical fixing at pad ends must keep metal out of contact with the tube. Bolt ends must also remain clear.

Large bearings glide in matching side panels

For this tube, make two semicircular altitude bearings from a 355.6 mm disc in 19.05 mm plywood. Edges must be round and square to their faces, with both rotation axes aligned. Bond laminate to the curved edges and keep the cradle attachments accessible for alignment corrections. A larger bearing travels farther across its pads for the same small angular turn, helping controlled movement. Stellafane: sizing and installing altitude bearings.

Before building the rocker, fit the finder and heaviest working eyepiece, then find balance. Measure rear-edge projection below the altitude axis; that determines the lower space needed as the tube rises. The source measures the complete assembly, not an empty tube. Stellafane: finding balance.

The rocker has two stiff matching sides, a front panel and a circular floor. Our dimensioned layout places the axis 609.6 mm above the floor’s upper face, with 254 mm side width. Sides are 19.05 mm plywood and the front 12.7 mm. A 288.925 mm front width leaves 3.175 mm total side clearance for the cradle. Its top is about 453.05 mm high; do not confuse original stock height with the final side edge after the circular relief is cut.

The cradle and side panel use different dimensional datums

Cradle end section

247.65

Side panel: axis and circular cutout

609.6254
Distancemm
Cradle top/bottom width222.25
Cradle side height260.35
Rocker cutout radius182.56
Axis above top of rocker floor609.6
Side edge after the cutout478.45
Front panel height453.05
Each panel uses equal x/y scales, but the two panels use different scales. Left: one end, four triangles and felt layers; the other end has four more. Bolts and pressure beams are schematic. Right: dashed stock before cutting, cross at the axis, lower arc as the cutout edge. Front height is measured from the actual side edge, not the dashed stock. Table dimensions are rounded; fit clearances to actual materials. Diagram basis: Stellafane; Side panel: axis and circular cutout.

Branch · Dimensional drawingOptional · you can skip this

Why 610 mm stock does not put the finished side edge at 610 mm

H=609.6 mm refers to the centre of the altitude-axis circle. The wooden bearing radius is 177.8 mm; this calculation adds 1.5875 mm laminate and 3.175 mm PTFE. The relief radius R꜀ and side-edge height Hₛ for width W=254 mm are:

R_(c) = 177.8 + 1.5875 + 3.175 = 182.5625 mm, H_(s) = H − √((R_(c))^(2) − (W/2)^(2)) ≈ 478.451 mm.

The drawing places the front another 25.4 mm below that actual side edge: Hfront≈453.051 mm. Subtracting 25.4 mm directly from H could leave a front panel that blocks the tube. Stellafane: original profile and rocker explanation.

Checking the rear also requires more than a vertical pose. For tail projection B, outside radius Rₒ and altitude α, the lowest corner of a rectangular envelope descends B sinα+Rₒ cosα below the axis. Its maximum over 0–90° is √(B²+Rₒ²). The hypothetical heavy load below gives B≈541.15 mm; minimum floor clearance is about 58.40 mm at roughly 79°, rather than exactly at zenith. This envelope omits projecting bolts: sweep the actual tube and cell through the required range.

Four PTFE pads support the side bearings; recess fastener heads below the sliding surface. Side retainers with soft pads prevent the cradle slipping sideways while preserving free motion. Check rocking, skew and collisions as the tube rises: plywood corners and pad positions can interfere before the optics do.

Three feet and three contact pads support the base

The circular rocker floor is 406.4 mm in diameter, as is the ground board’s outer circle. The rocker rectangle, including front thickness, fits inside: its diagonal is about 393.20 mm. Seal plywood edges against moisture and keep finish drips off working contacts.

Three feet sit 120° apart on the ground board, their centres at radius 177.8 mm. The source uses broad 76.2 mm diameter feet. Three 25.4 mm square PTFE pads work above their footprints, with pad centres at radius 184.15 mm. Each pad remains above a foot even though the centres are not identical. The laminated rocker underside glides over these contacts, while a central bolt defines the rotation axis. Do not tighten it like a clamp that removes the required clearance. Stellafane: ground board, feet and final assembly.

The pair of surfaces must give suitable starting and continuing motion. The historic Ebony Star pattern name does not guarantee the right texture: the documentation reports discontinuation of the required old finish. Check actual laminate and solid PTFE samples, cleanliness, recessed screws and pad placement. Then try small movements and release in both axes. Random lubrication or a tighter pivot does not explain the cause of a jerk. Stellafane: bearing materials.

An eyepiece change calls for checking both tube and telescope

Sliding the tube in its cradle changes its centre of mass relative to the altitude axis. A heavier eyepiece near the front needs a different position. Support the tube while shifting it, retighten the cradle and recheck retention. It must not swing uncontrollably upward when the eyepiece is removed either. Rotating the tube for eye comfort changes side-mass distribution, so check balance at several altitudes.

Base stability is a separate question. Even a balanced tube can stand on unstable soil or supports that are too narrow. First check all three contacts on a level firm surface, then free motion without foot lift, collisions or slippage. The model below separates those causes; it does not authorize a strong shove as a test.

Tube balance and base stability are different checks

Loads projected onto the tube axis

4 kg0.2 / 0.6 kg489.63541.150

Three-foot plan: mm, equal scale

0 N5 N10 N
Side force, Ny coordinate, mmReactions R1/R2/R3, N
0026.15 / 26.15 / 26.15
5-50.9911.15 / 33.65 / 33.65
10-101.97-3.85 / 41.15 / 41.15
Hypothetical example, not a physical test: 4 kg without an eyepiece, axial centre 460 mm from the rear; 0.2/0.6 kg eyepieces at the focuser plane. Radial offsets are omitted on the left. Right: total mass 8 kg, initial mass projection at the base centre, force applied 800 mm high towards the bottom triangle edge. Full circular feet are shown, but the conservative calculation treats their centres as point supports. A negative reaction means contact is lost, not that a foot pulls the base down. Stiffness, soil, wind and dynamics are not modelled. Diagram basis: Stellafane.

Branch · StaticsOptional · you can skip this

An eyepiece changes torque; a push changes foot reactions

Take a hypothetical 4 kg bare tube with axial centre 460 mm from its rear. Apply the eyepiece at the focuser plane, x=1082.167 mm. These are simplified loads for our geometry, not measured Stellafane masses. For masses mᵢ at coordinates xᵢ, the axial centre is:

x_(G) = (∑m_(i)x_(i))/(∑m_(i)).

A 0.2 kg eyepiece gives 489.627 mm, and 0.6 kg gives 541.152 mm, a 51.525 mm difference. Swapping heavy for light requires sliding the tube forward about 51.5 mm relative to the cradle in this axial model. Independently verify zero moment by adding mᵢg(xᵢ−xG).

But an eyepiece projects sideways. If its position has radial offset y in the altitude plane, the horizontal gravity arm depends on α:

τ_(g) = mg[(x − x_(A))cos⁡α − ysin⁡α].

Here xA is the altitude axis’s coordinate along the tube; convert lengths to metres for N·m. Our sign indicates which side gravity acts on. Even with x=xA, 0.6 kg at y=190 mm gives about 1.118 N·m at zenith. Longitudinal sliding cannot cancel it there. A suitable mass orientation or distribution, or a separate counterweight arrangement, is required; actual friction has not been measured here.

For the base, assume total mass M=8 kg and its initial mass projection at the centre. Conservatively replace the circular feet with points at their centres. They form a triangle with an 88.9 mm distance to the nearest edge. A side force F at height h shifts the resultant load point:

\boldsymbol r_{\rm eff}=\boldsymbol r_G+\frac{h\boldsymbol F}{Mg}.

At h=800 mm, 5 N towards the lower edge shifts it about 50.99 mm, inside the triangle. A 10 N force gives 101.97 mm, outside: equilibrium would require a negative reaction at one foot, but a free foot cannot pull on the floor. This marks contact loss in a rigid static model. Independently check that vertical reactions sum to Mg and satisfy moment equilibrium. Wind, movement, ground slope and flexibility need further checks. The 5/10 N examples are not rated strength or safety limits.

Final acceptance connects mechanics, focus and alignment

Once every assembly is secure, collimate: coordinate the positions and directions of the optical elements. A suitable sight tube or Cheshire is enough to begin. First position the actual secondary edge under the focuser, then aim the secondary at the primary centre mark, and finally adjust the primary using the tool’s target. Corrections interact, so recheck earlier steps. Stellafane: collimation sequence.

Three steps have three different targets

  1. Position the secondary

    The actual secondary edge looks round and sits under the focuser. Ignore reflections for now.

  2. Aim the secondary

    The sight-tube crosshairs point at the primary centre mark.

  3. Aim the primary

    The primary mark coincides with the centre of the bright Cheshire ring. Do not force the offset secondary shadow to be concentric.

A target-selection map, not a simulated photograph through an eyepiece. Circles and the displaced shadow are schematic, not a scaled prediction of offset. Recheck earlier steps after an adjustment, then check on a star after cooling. Diagram basis: Stellafane.

Not every reflected circle must be concentric: secondary offset may leave an asymmetric shadow. Distinguish its physical edge, the primary reflection and the specific Cheshire target. A manufacturer’s separate manual shows normal asymmetry in a full-offset system; do not transfer its numbers to our slower Yellow. Sky-Watcher: offset and collimation, p.8.

After cooling, check a star near field centre, recentering it after adjustments. Atmospheric motion and a warm mirror change the image; pinched optics, focuser flex and misalignment need different actions. Return to the specific suspected cause instead of turning every screw.

For first acceptance, record actual results: all eyepieces reach distant focus with reserve; the mirror is secure without squeezing; alignment survives altitude changes; the cradle does not slip; both bearings move smoothly; tube and projections avoid collisions; and the feet stay in contact. These requirements are explained here through documentation and models. There is no completed physical-test record of our own.

The opening problem can now be separated into causes: spontaneous tube movement comes from torque or unsuitable sliding, jerks from a contact or skew, missing focus from distances, and blurred images also from support and alignment. A useful next step is a dimensioned record of your parts and a trial optical assembly before the final cut, following the instructions. Making each assembly is meaningful together with checking its intended function.